By GREGORY R. NORFLEET
MT. VERNON — The Fifth District Appellate Court last week threw out a class-action lawsuit against microchip giant Intel Corp. that was approved by a Madison County circuit court.
In an 11-page ruling, a three-justice panel found that the case should have been filed in California and that there are not enough connections to Illinois to justify a case here, instead.
Madison County’s court system was heavily criticized in the 2004 Illinois Supreme Court race as a “judicial hellhole” that attracted numerous class-action lawsuits and then awarded huge monetary damages to plaintiffs. Those accusations have been leveled again this year in the race for the open seat of the Fifth District Appellate Court.
In the case of Barbara’s Sales Inc. et al v. Intel and Hewlett-Packard Co., Justice Richard Goldenhersh ruled that the plaintiff’s argument that the Pentium 4 processor is no better than the Pentium III should be filed in California because that’s Intel’s headquarters.
With Justices Melissa Chapman and Terrance Hopkins concurring, the court used a six-point test to render its ruling. It found that, while Intel microprocessing chips are sold in products throughout the 50 states, California has multiple ties to this case not found anywhere else.
California is where the chips are both designed and manufactured, to start, and the marketing strategy to sell the chips — with the claim the chips were far superior to even its own Pentium III — was developed there as well, the court ruled.
“With this in mind, we conclude that California’s interest in the conduct of Intel is the most significant,” read the ruling.
“We find that California has the most significant relationship to the occurrence and to the parties,” wrote the court. “California law, not Illinois law, is applicable. Accordingly, we vacate the order of the circuit court of Madison County regarding class certification.”
The ruling was issued July 25.
By GREGORY R. NORFLEET
Farrington Grade School pursues Internet upgrade
Farrington Grade School is upgrading to a wireless Internet system to improve network speeds and offer more learning opportunities for students.Continued ...
Cove Connection to begin next round of parenting classes
The Cove Connection Community Parenting Group will begin its next round of mentoring classes Aug. 5, and local parents still have time to sign up for the next session.Continued ...
Collins appointed to RLCD
MT. VERNON — Perhaps the third time will be the charm for County Chairman Robert White in appointing a trustee to the Rend Lake Conservancy District.White announced during a special meeting conducted by the County Board on Thursday night he has appoiContinued ...
Christmas inthe Park revived
MT. VERNON — After a year hiatus, the Christmas in the Park program will be back this holiday season.“We skipped last year,” said coordinator Don Bigham. “We couldn’t get a chairperson. I was occupied, Gene Tucker was occupied and no one was able toContinued ...
MVTHS holds pre-bid meeting
MT. VERNON — Roughly 40 trade contractors attended a special pre-bid meeting Thursday to learn more about the ongoing rebidding of the new proposed Mt. Vernon Township High School.The informal session gave potential bidders an overview of the newly rContinued ...
- County Board calls last minute meeting
- MVTHS to hold pre-bid meeting
- Alleged arsonist pleads innocent
- Deer hunting changes released
- Bridge letting Aug. 1
- United Way selects theme
- MVTHS gears up for semester
- Clinical trial proves positive
- Gold Wing Rally to visit
- Republic adjusts first bill
- Farrington Grade School pursues Internet upgrade