By GREGORY R. NORFLEET
MT. VERNON — The Fifth District Appellate Court last week threw out a class-action lawsuit against microchip giant Intel Corp. that was approved by a Madison County circuit court.
In an 11-page ruling, a three-justice panel found that the case should have been filed in California and that there are not enough connections to Illinois to justify a case here, instead.
Madison County’s court system was heavily criticized in the 2004 Illinois Supreme Court race as a “judicial hellhole” that attracted numerous class-action lawsuits and then awarded huge monetary damages to plaintiffs. Those accusations have been leveled again this year in the race for the open seat of the Fifth District Appellate Court.
In the case of Barbara’s Sales Inc. et al v. Intel and Hewlett-Packard Co., Justice Richard Goldenhersh ruled that the plaintiff’s argument that the Pentium 4 processor is no better than the Pentium III should be filed in California because that’s Intel’s headquarters.
With Justices Melissa Chapman and Terrance Hopkins concurring, the court used a six-point test to render its ruling. It found that, while Intel microprocessing chips are sold in products throughout the 50 states, California has multiple ties to this case not found anywhere else.
California is where the chips are both designed and manufactured, to start, and the marketing strategy to sell the chips — with the claim the chips were far superior to even its own Pentium III — was developed there as well, the court ruled.
“With this in mind, we conclude that California’s interest in the conduct of Intel is the most significant,” read the ruling.
“We find that California has the most significant relationship to the occurrence and to the parties,” wrote the court. “California law, not Illinois law, is applicable. Accordingly, we vacate the order of the circuit court of Madison County regarding class certification.”
The ruling was issued July 25.
By GREGORY R. NORFLEET
Car hits motorcycle on Broadway
Mt. Vernon Police Department is investigating a two-vehicle accident about 2 p.m. Wednesday in the 3400 block of Broadway.Continued ...
MVTHS School Report Card data won't change
Mt. Vernon Township High School's 2012-2013 state test results will remain the same as what's listed in the district's recently released School Report Card.Continued ...
Aggregate plan helping residents save
MT. VERNON -- Residents who are in the city's electric aggregate are seeing a 14 percent savings over last year, according to Jeff Haarmann of Affordable Gas and Electric. "We initially anticipated a 26 percent savings for those in the aggregate," HaContinued ...
Christmas Parade to light up town
MT. VERNON -- Downtown will be lit with a "Star-Spangled Christmas" for the Christmas parade on Saturday. According to parade organizer John Scrivner, the theme was chosen in honor of the anniversary of the attack on Pearl Harbor. He expects the floaContinued ...
Grinch to visit the Granada
MT. VERNON -- Residents will be able to enjoy a childhood favorite film during the Granada Theater showing of "How the Grinch Stole Christmas." An annual tradition, the Dr. Seuss classic film will be shown at 4 p.m. at the theater, with doors openingContinued ...
- Six sheriff candidates in primary
- Operation Love offers hot meals
- Six sheriff candidates seek office
- Sting targets disabled parking violations
- NAACP to hold workshop
- Levy reflects pension issues
- Church presents Living Christmas Tree
- Two injuredin car accident
- Secretary of State Police hold parking sting in Mt. Vernon
- UMCH gears up for Live Nativity
- Car hits motorcycle on Broadway